Thursday, November 29, 2007

Pac 10 Official All But Admits Improper Use of Replay in Stanford Game

It's been a few days since the most blatantly awful replay review of all time, so I think it's time we take a look at what has shaken down in these days in the immediate aftermath of this travesty.

For one, we finally got a public statement from the head of Pac 10 Officiating, Dave Cutaia. In an e-mail he sent out in response to the criticism of the play, he is quoted as saying:

"The replay official felt he had a shot that showed the point of the ball hit the ground...

*First Lie.

...This is basically a judgment call on his part, as an on-field official might judge defensive pass interference.

*Second Lie.

So, let's look at the first part of the statement. The replay official found a shot... no, wait, scratch that... felt he found a shot that conclusively showed (whoops, he didn't use the word "conclusively") the point of the ball hitting the ground. Hey, that's not bad. It's an empirically-testable statement. Now obviously it wasn't any shot that we had available to us, the television-watching audience, because that one clearly did not meet the burden of proof. Ahhh, so it was a secret camera angle that wasn't available to the TV broadcast, right? They do have secret angles, don't they?
Q. What will be the source of the video for replays?
A. All reviewable video will come direct from the television production of the game.

(From the official replay policy)

Allright, no worries. Let's pretend you did have a secret reverse-angle shot that the television networks just didn't decide to put in their broadcast. It probably would have looked something like this shot taken by an on-field photographer:

Which even more conclusively shows that his hand is under the ball.

Moving swiftly along to lie number two...
This is basically a judgment call on his part, as an on-field official might judge defensive pass interference.

Now I'm just a simple caveman, but to me it sounds like Cutaia is admitting that the replay was improperly administered. Either that, or he doesn't know the rules of instant replay set down by the same conference that he is apparently in charge of officiating. You see, the second line of the aforementioned official document on instant replay clearly states:
Standard: There must be indisputable video evidence for an on-field officiating decision to be changed by the Instant Replay Official working from a private booth in the press box.

That underlining was not done by me for emphasis, that's exactly how it appears on the website. But, wait, there must be some wiggle room for a replay official's judgment call, right? I'll do a search of their rulebook for the word "judgment":

So anybody who has taken the time to read the first paragraph of the replay policy (a group which may or may not contain Cutaia) can sufficiently agree that replay is definitively not a "judgment call" and is, moreover, fundamentally opposite from judgment calls like defensive pass interference. Instead it requires, (everyone together now) indisputable video evidence, which Cutaia all but comes out and admits was not the standard of proof used in this specific reversal. The replay officials acted blatantly against their authority... it's black letter law.

Cutaia then declined to make public the names of the officials involved. Perhaps a smart move, what with all the crazies out there, but it still reeks of an institutional refusal to make anybody take accountability for what, in Cuataia's own words, was a clear-cut incorrect ruling. At any rate, it's these two guys. If anyone can track down a directory of Pac 10 officials with mug shots, it should be pretty easy to find out who these incompetent bozos are and keep track on whether or not they've been fired or reprimanded.

Labels: , , , , , ,


At 10:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

wow, that "on-field photographer" must have been 200 feet tall! but seriously, nice post.

At 3:50 PM, Anonymous gwzimm said...

Magnificent post, you lovable sarcastic bastard

At 7:25 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You simply MUST get a life. Only ND fans could complain for this long over a call in a game YOU WON.

At 9:32 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

it's been a month and the hate still flows through me. what a beautiful thing ruined by some PAC10 douchebag.

At 1:06 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Gret work....and to the guy who thinks we should get a life...yea, we should get a life...the point here is that the PAC 10 is NOTORIOUS for failing on the field and in the booth. Yea we won, but should we wait until we get the distinction of me a favor, take your attitude to politics where mediocrity is embraced as excellence...jerk...

At 12:24 PM, Anonymous dawgy said...

Sorry but, the worst replay screw up of all time had to be on the onside kick in last year's Oklahoma/Oregon game.

At 11:21 PM, Blogger addirigib said...

Wonderful post. Interesting blog it is. i can make my college project with Essay reviews online writing company. And it is also teach about making articles.

At 1:50 AM, Blogger Safety vest said...

Thanks for sharing. I really appreciate it that you shared with us such informative post, great tips and very easy to understand.Safety vest

At 1:22 AM, Blogger Shan Jonson said...

Once aloft a time, aggregate was fabricated by hand. Anniversary account had to be crafted individually; it took consistently because there was no standardization. Man grasped the abstraction of application patterns, templates and molds to accomplish identical genitalia for after assembly, accomplishment ability took a abundant bound forward.

At 7:08 AM, Blogger sofialery said...

Thanks for sharing. The is just about easy essay writing website.

At 6:04 AM, Blogger Anaa Angel said...

You're the best with the end goal of stunning counsel appearing to this online journal page. All
individuals choose. I'm sure exceptionally upbeat to look out this astonishing web website. Write my college paper

At 9:22 AM, Blogger Albert Smith said...

The replays play an important role in helping referees to make their decisions. If they are not used properly the game wont be fair. The is an immense need to train the technical team and the referees on how to use replays.
Affordable School assignment aid

At 5:27 AM, Blogger Alex Milner said...

Making replays helps in checking on the errors that could have been manly. This helps in avoiding unfair decisions on the participants. Just as it is in football, one need also to play in the job field well to get the best chance.LOR letters Writing Needed? | Recommendation letters Help. This will land you to where you wished to be.

At 4:34 AM, Blogger Kara Smith said...

why you looking for movie conversion then you have app like showbox all movies you love are available in HD formats in showbox app even all tv series loved by all is also available so just simply get showbox and make your life easy and entertaining.
showbox apk

At 4:17 AM, Blogger Michael Jones said...

Well done! Congrats on managing your site so well. It is one of the best sites that i have visited. We are an Assignment Help online provider that assists the students in writing courswork on many subjects. Students can try our writing service if they have trouble in writing their assignment.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home